Some films get a rare second chance to shine—and Caught Stealing is proof that a box office stumble doesn’t always mean the end. The gritty R-rated crime thriller, directed by Darren Aronofsky, has found new life on Netflix after its theatrical debut in 2025 left audiences divided.
Set in the chaotic, punk-infused streets of 1990s New York City, Caught Stealing delivers a fast-paced narrative packed with gang rivalries, dark humor, and relentless action. While the film initially struggled to connect with moviegoers during its August 29, 2025, cinema release—earning only $32 million against its $40 million budget—it has quickly gained traction since hitting streaming platforms on November 29, 2025.
Netflix has proven to be the perfect home for this edgy crime drama. The platform’s audience has embraced its raw energy, razor-sharp visuals, and charismatic performances, turning Caught Stealing into a sleeper hit. Critics have joined in, awarding the film an impressive 84% on Rotten Tomatoes and praising its pulpy, street-level atmosphere.
At the heart of the movie is Austin Butler in the role of Hank Thompson, a once-promising baseball star whose career takes an unexpected turn. Now working as a bartender in New York, Hank’s quiet life spirals into chaos after he agrees to care for his neighbor’s cat—unwittingly stepping into a dangerous world of gangsters, underground dealings, and violent confrontations.
Butler’s captivating performance is matched by the fierce presence of Zoë Kravitz as his punk-rock neighbor, whose world draws him into danger. The ensemble cast is further bolstered by powerhouse performances from Regina King, Matt Smith, and global music star Bad Bunny, whose role injects an extra dose of flair into the gritty narrative.
The film blends dark comedy with adrenaline-pumping action sequences, delivering an unapologetic portrait of New York’s criminal underworld. Audiences can expect high-stakes drama, unexpected twists, and a visually striking mix of punk culture and noir storytelling.
With its revival on Netflix, Caught Stealing has transitioned from overlooked summer title to must-watch crime thriller. Whether you missed its theatrical run or simply crave a high-energy ride through the dangerous backstreets of 90s New York, this Darren Aronofsky-directed film is now poised to capture your attention.
